/kai-monthly-audit — A Month of Signal Turned Into Decisions

Kai root note: knowledge/, harness/, and scripts/ paths in this skill live in the Kai install, not the user's project. Resolve them against the first ancestor directory of this SKILL.md that contains a knowledge/ folder (the Kai plugin root, ~/.claude/kai, or the kai-cmo-harness repo). MARKETING.md, memory/, and any output files live in the current project. If a referenced scripts/ command is not available in this install, say so, skip it, and continue with the file-based guidance — never fabricate its output.

Objective

An executive review of the last 30 days where every number resolves to a source, every channel gets a keep/change/stop decision, and the month ends with a prioritized next-month plan that names owners and skills. Weekly signals become a narrative; the narrative becomes budget and channel decisions. An unsourced finding is not a finding — a scorecard with a guessed number is worse than one with a gray cell.

Done when

Work type audit-report (also_covers: monthly-audit) — floor E3/C4/O1 (harness/eco-floors.yaml).

• E3 — a named human approved the exact delivered file, hash-pinned, and every quantitative claim in it resolves to a collector source inside the month's audit folder.
• C4 — the Kai Data Provenance Rule is satisfied end to end: collector run before writing, data mode declared, every number carrying source plus retrieval date plus artifact path, banned_word_check clean, and audit_provenance_lint passing on the folder.
• O1 — every P0 recommendation in the next-month plan names the metric it targets, its baseline, its threshold, and its owner. An audit whose top recommendation has no metric is not finished. Adoption is read at 60 days.

Constraints

Data provenance is the non-negotiable. Load harness/references/audit-data-provenance.md before writing any finding.

• Declare the data mode: sales_external for prospect and public-only month-end audits · onboarding_connected when GSC, GA4, GBP, ads, CRM, call tracking, or client exports are connected · internal_demo when sample data is used, labeled as such.
• Never publish traffic, conversions, calls, rankings, ad metrics, revenue, review counts, Core Web Vitals, backlinks, Domain Rating, or local pack claims without source, retrieval date, and artifact path.
• Missing sources become _data-gaps.md entries. They never become estimates.
• Channel pulls when relevant: python scripts/ads/pull_all.py · python -m scripts.content.tracker_cli report --format json · python -m scripts.analytics.performance_dashboard weekly · python -m scripts.analytics.scheduled_pull --all.
• Use --third-party-sources all or a specific comma list only when licensed vendor data is available and needed.

Collector before writing, connected collectors only when access is confirmed, provenance lint before handoff:

python -m scripts.audit.collect --url "<url>" --mode <mode> --workflow kai-monthly-audit --out workspace/audits/monthly/<YYYY-MM> --pagespeed
python -m scripts.audit.collect --url "<url>" --mode onboarding_connected --workflow kai-monthly-audit --out workspace/audits/monthly/<YYYY-MM> --pagespeed --places --dataforseo --seo-provider auto --gsc --ga4 --calls --date-from "<YYYY-MM-DD>" --date-to "<YYYY-MM-DD>"
python scripts/quality_gates/audit_provenance_lint.py workspace/audits/monthly/<YYYY-MM> --audit-dir

Other binding rules:

• Score only source-eligible findings. Mark unsupported areas gray and list the data gap next to them.
• Separate facts from hypotheses. A hypothesis may become an experiment; it may not become a client-facing finding.
• Budget guidance rules: keep budget when efficiency and volume are stable · shift budget when one channel is source-backed and materially stronger · reduce budget when measurement is broken or spend is not connected to outcomes · never recommend a budget increase from inferred data.
• KaiCalls fit rule. Evaluate phone-based lead capture when the business appears phone-led. Recommend KaiCalls only on source-backed fit signals (missed calls, after-hours, speed-to-lead, qualification, routing, call logging), disclose Kai ownership, and compare alternatives. Do not lead with it when phone demand is low or the workflow is self-serve by design.
• The audit recommends. It does not change budgets, pause campaigns, or mutate any live channel.

Know these before collecting (read MARKETING.md and the latest weekly audit folders first; ask only for what blocks a sourced review): the target URL · the data mode · which sources are actually connected · current monthly budget · the primary KPI. Also establish business stage, active channels, target conversion events, the offer, budget posture, and known constraints.

Context

Need	Load
Provenance rule, modes, collector contract	harness/references/audit-data-provenance.md
ECO floor and craft note for audits	harness/eco-floors.yaml
Prior-period comparison	Latest folders under workspace/audits/
Business stage, channels, offer, constraints	MARKETING.md (project root)
Phone-led conversion diagnosis	knowledge/checklists/cro-audit-checklist.md
Client-ready deck version	/kai-html-presentation

Audit modules — run the ones the month's activity justifies:

Module	Trigger
/kai-audit	Always, for full marketing health.
/kai-seo-audit	Website, organic search, local visibility, AEO, or technical SEO.
/kai-cro	Landing pages, checkout, booking, demos, forms, or phone-led conversion.
/kai-daily-ad-review summary	Paid media active this month.
/content-report and /content-retro	Content published this month, or aging content due for review.
/kai-analytics	Tracking gaps, attribution conflicts, missing KPI definitions.
/kai-growth-plan	Strategic uncertainty, budget allocation, or stage mismatch.

Executive scorecard — every row scored /100 with a trend, sourced evidence, and a decision:

Area	Score	Trend	Evidence	Decision
Demand	/100	up/down/flat	sourced	keep/change/stop
Conversion	/100	up/down/flat	sourced	keep/change/stop
Search and AEO	/100	up/down/flat	sourced	keep/change/stop
Paid media	/100	up/down/flat	sourced	keep/change/stop
Lifecycle	/100	up/down/flat	sourced	keep/change/stop
Reputation and calls	/100	up/down/flat	sourced	keep/change/stop
Measurement	/100	up/down/flat	sourced	keep/change/stop

Strategic learning answers seven questions: what improved · what got worse · what repeated across weekly audits · what surprised us · what to stop · what to double down on · what data we still cannot trust.

Next-month plan is a P0/P1/P2 table with columns: Priority · Action · Owner · Skill · Due · Source.

Output — workspace/audits/monthly/<YYYY-MM>/ holds _data-sources.md, _data-gaps.md, audit-data.json, kai-data.json, _executive-summary.md, _monthly-scorecard.md, _detailed-findings.md, _strategic-learning.md, _next-month-plan.md, _skill-routing.md, and html-presentation/index.html. Monthly decks read like an executive review: fewer slides, clearer decisions, every number sourced.

Escalate when

• Connected-source access is claimed but the collector cannot retrieve it — do not fall back to public data while presenting it as connected.
• The month's most important channel has no measurable data and the scorecard would be mostly gray.
• Attribution across sources conflicts materially and no single source can be named authoritative.
• The obvious recommendation requires spend or a channel change the user has not authorized.
• Weekly audits and this month's collector data disagree on the same metric.
• The business is phone-led but call data is unavailable, so conversion cannot be honestly scored.