review-ipc

Audit the IPC layer across the SDK, permission gate, and host listener for correctness and completeness.

Context: the worker/view bridge

Every Tier 2 extension runs in two iframes — a worker (always-on, hidden, worker.html) and a view (on-demand, view.html). Each iframe imports from a different SDK entry (asyar-sdk/worker vs asyar-sdk/view) and owns its own MessageBroker and ExtensionContext. The IPC bridge audited here therefore covers both iframes' calls into the host. ExtensionIpcRouter maps event.source back to a role via findIframeRoleForSource(...) — services that branch on role read it off the dispatch context.

For the runtime details (state machine, mailbox, RPC), see docs/explanation/extension-runtime.md; for the per-message protocol, see docs/explanation/ipc-bridge.md.

What to check

1. Type string format consistency

All SDK proxy methods must call broker.invoke('{service}:{action}', ...). The MessageBroker prepends asyar:api: automatically, producing asyar:api:{service}:{action}. Verify:

• Every this.broker.invoke(...) call in asyar-sdk/src/services/*Proxy.ts uses the {service}:{action} format (no asyar:api: prefix — that's added by MessageBroker)
• The resulting full type (asyar:api:{service}:{action}) is classified in the Rust gate — asyar-launcher/src-tauri/src/permissions.rs: either get_required_permission (needs a manifest permission) or is_public_call (deliberately permission-free). That is the ONLY enforcement point — there is no JS-side gate to update
• The gate fails closed (since 2026-07-24): a call type in neither list is DENIED, so a new proxy method nobody classified breaks loudly instead of becoming default-allowed
• New proxies are added to the right entry's bag: the worker entry (asyar-sdk/src/worker.ts) only exposes proxies that don't depend on the DOM or user interaction; the view entry (asyar-sdk/src/view.ts) exposes the full bag — it re-exports contracts.ts, which is where the shared proxies and ExtensionContext live. A misclassified proxy is a Phase-6 regression.

2. Permission gate coverage

Coverage is auto-enforced by asyar-launcher/scripts/permission-coverage.test.mjs (runs in CI via vitest): it extracts every .invoke('service:action') call type in the SDK and fails if any is not classified in the Rust gate (get_required_permission ∪ is_public_call). A forgotten mapping turns CI red — you no longer hand-audit this.

When adding/auditing a gated API, edit asyar-launcher/src-tauri/src/permissions.rs:

• Add gated calls to get_required_permission — the permission string must be a valid manifest permission (e.g. clipboard:read, network, fs:read, runs:track, tools:register). The generated gatedPermissions.ts (launcher + SDK CLI copies) is derived from it by scripts/generate-permission-catalog.mjs — run pnpm gen:permission-catalog
• Add deliberately permission-free calls to is_public_call (with a one-line rationale) — do NOT rely on fall-through, which now denies
• Verify with pnpm exec vitest run scripts/permission-coverage.test.mjs and cargo test permissions::tests

3. Tier 1 action registration

Tier 1 (built-in) extensions must not use ActionServiceProxy for registering actions. Callbacks are stripped by JSON.stringify in postMessage serialization.

Check every file in asyar-launcher/src/built-in-features/*/index.ts:

• Actions must be registered via actionService.registerAction(...) (the host singleton imported from ../../services/action/actionService.svelte)
• Any use of context.getService<IActionService>('actions') for registering callbacks should be flagged

4. IPC response path

Verify that for any new service method added to a proxy:

• The host-side handler exists in asyar-launcher/src/services/extension/ExtensionIpcRouter.ts or a dedicated service file
• Replies are posted with event.source.postMessage({ type: 'asyar:response', messageId, result }, '*') on success — using event.source ensures the reply lands in the same iframe (worker or view) that issued the request
• Error path sends { type: 'asyar:response', messageId, error: string }
• Host → iframe pushes that target a specific role go through pickExtensionIframe(extensionId, prefer) in asyar-launcher/src/services/extension/extensionIframeSelector.ts — never an unscoped iframe[data-extension-id="..."] selector

5. Role-aware dispatch checks (Phase 6+)

When auditing services that branch on iframe role:

• actions.registerActionHandler is role-neutral — registering from either role is supported and the launcher routes the matching asyar:action:execute envelope back to whichever role registered
• commands.onCommand for a mode: "background" manifest command must register from the worker; the launcher dispatches background-mode commands to the worker iframe
• state:rpcRequest / state:rpcReply envelopes carry the worker↔view RPC protocol; the worker-side interceptor in asyar-sdk/src/worker.ts is the only place that calls extensionRpc.deliverActionPayload(...). View-side calls go through context.request(...) only.

Files to read

• asyar-sdk/src/ipc/MessageBroker.ts — confirms broker.invoke() prepends asyar:api:
• asyar-sdk/src/services/*Proxy.ts — all proxy service files
• asyar-sdk/src/worker.ts, asyar-sdk/src/view.ts, asyar-sdk/src/contracts.ts — entry-point split
• asyar-launcher/src-tauri/src/permissions.rs — the real gate (get_required_permission + is_public_call + gate_decision, fail-closed)
• asyar-launcher/scripts/permission-coverage.test.mjs — the CI coverage gate (SDK call types ⊆ classified)
• asyar-launcher/src/services/extension/ExtensionIpcRouter.ts — host IPC handler + role-source mapping
• asyar-launcher/src/services/extension/extensionIframeSelector.ts — pickExtensionIframe role-prefer/fallback selector
• asyar-launcher/src/built-in-features/*/index.ts — Tier 1 action registration

Host → Extension Push Messages (out of scope for this audit)

The host sends two push message types directly into extension iframes. These are not extension API calls — they originate from the host and require no permission gate:

Message type	Direction	Purpose
asyar:theme:variables	host → iframe	Injects all CSS custom properties on load and on theme change
asyar:theme:fonts	host → iframe	Sends Satoshi + JetBrains Mono as base64 @font-face CSS on load

Sender: ExtensionIframe.svelte (handleIframeLoad, MutationObserver) Receiver: ExtensionContext.ts setupThemeInjection() in the SDK

These are host→iframe pushes, not extension calls, so they never reach the gate — do not flag them as missing.

Output format

Report findings grouped by category:

1. Missing permission gate entries — type string + which proxy method
2. Tier 1 proxy misuse — file + line where ActionServiceProxy is misused
3. Orphaned gate entries — call types in get_required_permission/is_public_call with no matching SDK .invoke() (dead classification)
4. IPC response path gaps — proxy methods with no corresponding host handler
5. Clean — explicitly state if a category has no issues

If the request names a single service (e.g. "review-ipc for notifications"), scope the review to that service only.